Prima Oliva

Imported Oils and Vinegars

Prima Oliva features a collection of estate-produced and award winning cold pressed extra virgin olive oils under our private label. We also offer an extensive selection of the finest traditionally aged and naturally flavored balsamic vinegars from Modena, Italy. Our offerings are the freshest, highest-quality oils and balsamic vinegars available.

Taste the Difference! Olive oils only look similar–our vast array of olive varietals creates a unique ability for the consumer to find the best possible choice specific to their unique palate. Taste several to find the oil that’s best for you!

To compare taste, try several varieties of olive oil. You’ll be surprised at the variations of flavor and texture. As an educated consumer, the opportunity now exists to taste a wide range of extra virgin olive oils. There is no substitute for individual experience, so enjoy as many extra virgin olive oils as you can. Each one represents an extraordinary example of unique quality and value. These are flavors that you just can’t get in traditional supermarket brands.

If you can’t make it to Hamburg, we also have a location in East Aurora at 650 Main Street on the same block as Tantalus.


  • Monday – Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
  • Saturday: 9:00 am – 5:00 pm
  • Sunday: Closed